Steve Lundberg does not represent me. He claims to represent the supply side of the New Zealand Information and Communications Technology industry (see the note at the end of http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:wzDfoNHqC5YJ:www.patents4software.com/%3Fp%3D72) and he advocates for software patents in New Zealand. But I have been writing software for over 30 years and I don't want software patents in New Zealand or anywhere. Steve Lundberg does not represent me.
It is interesting, and I am sure no coincidence, that the U-turn of the New Zealand government on the issue of software patents was leaked by a US based patent lawyer. I suspect Mr Lundberg works for US interests, not the interests of New Zealand. No doubt, those interests he is working for are interested in extracting as much value as they can from New Zealand. He is very pleased with the U-turn, and that is all the more reason for everyone in New Zealand to be very displeased.
Software patents are the tools of large global companies that can afford patent portfolios and legal teams and use them to eliminate competition. They provide little prospect of benefit and great risk of harm to New Zealand (or anywhere or anyone else except for those few mamoth companies that will never have anything but sales offices, lawyers and "tax" collecters here in New Zealand). Consider the absurdity of patents that have been issued in the United States and Europe. Consider the reality of a small company defending a patent and, worse, the reality of a small company defending itself against claims of patent violation. Consider that the largest companies in New Zealand are worth less than lunch for the legal teams of the big players in the software industry.
Even if one admits merit in software patents (I don't, but many do) then they should be rejected on the basis that the cost of mediating and enforcing the privileges granted by patents exceeds the value of what is patented. It is fundamentally unjust that defending oneself against even frivolous claims of patent infringement can bankrupt a person or business. Even if patents do encourage development that benefits society, this benefit must be weighed against the lost benefit of development that is discouraged by the risk of costs associated with defending oneself against claims of patent infringement.
No comments:
Post a Comment